News
On the Controversy in Kano and the Planned Public Debate
Muhammad Shakir Balogun
Hausa-speaking Muslims are looking forward to a debate coming up in Kano later this month. This ‘debate’ appears to be the latest iteration of the historical encounter that has pitched those who have raised objections to the validity of Sunni Prophetic traditions and the narrative integrity of the Companions of the Prophet against those who have upheld same.
The former includes orientalists, Shi’ites, Mu’tazilites and reformist/modernist Sunni Muslims while the latter are Orthodox Sunni scholars from both Salafi/Athari/Izala and Ash’ari/Sufi persuasions.
The trustworthiness of the ultimate transmitters of hadiths and the validity of the recorded traditions of the Prophet constitute the bone of contention. In Sunni Islam, since al-Shafi’i, authentic hadiths have been regarded as revealed truth just like the Qur’an, and with similar legislative powers. They are unimpeachable.
“There is absolutely nothing new about what Shaikh AbdulJabaar Nasir Kabara, the outspoken scion of the famous Kabara scholarly and Sufi dynasty of Kano, has been saying. He has articulated them in his books to which rebuttals have been penned by local scholars.”
![]()
The same arguments have been more eloquently articulated by orientalists like David Samuel Margoliouth, Ignaz Goldziher, Joseph Schacht, and GHA Joynboll; the Egyptians like Muhammad Taufiq Sidqi (of the ‘Qur’an only’ school), Mahmud Abu Rayyah, Ahmed Subhy Mansour, and Muhammad Abu Zayd; the Indians like Chiragh Ali, Aslam Jairajpuri, Abdullah Chakralawi who were mostly of the ‘Qur’an only’ school, and numerous scholars from the Shi’ite camp.
Muhammad Tawfiq Sidqi was engaged by Taha al-Bishri and Salih al-Yafi’i in a series of exchanges on the pages of al-Manar which culminated with his recanting. Prominent among those who have passionately written to defend the Sunnah, as enshrined in recorded hadiths, in modern times are the Syrian Mustafa Siba’i (he specifically incorporated a rebuttal to Abu Rayyah in his book) and Muhammad Ali Sabuni, and the Indian Muhammad Mustafa Azmi. These books are there for those who want to independently follow the arguments.
But can arguments, rebuttals and counter-rebuttals extensively articulated in numerous books be satisfactorily covered in public debates? How many hours or days have been earmarked for the debate? What is the possible outcome of an exchange in which the interlocutors differ fundamentally in methodology and hate each other’s guts?
Can a debate already poisoned by hot polemics and ad hominem attacks really lead anywhere?
Shaikh AbdulJabbaar has impugned the characters of people considered by Sunnis to be beyond reproach like the Companions of the Prophet such as Umar (the second caliph), Anas (the personal attendant of the Prophet), Abu Hurairah (the most prolific transmitter of Prophetic traditions). He has also attacked hadith luminaries like az-Zuhri, al-Bukhari, and Muslim.
He has pummeled Mu’awiyah, the first Omayyad caliph, whose historical legacy is mixed even by Orthodox Sunni accounts, but who is nonetheless counted among the Companions and given a pass.
These are people held in high regard by Sunni Muslims. He has described them as deceivers, hypocrites, and liars. He has also castigated the illustrious exponents of the Salafi methodology such as ibn Taimiyyah, ibnul Qayyim, adh-Dhahabi, ibn Kathir. This is a frontal attack. Ibn Hajar, the great exegete of al-Bukhari’s collection has also not been spared.
AbdulJabbaar has thrown spears at the very heart of Orthodox Islam. He has been boastful and confrontational, and frequently accuses his contemporary adversaries of insincerity, mendacity and ignorance.
“I have personally observed that his translations from Arabic texts are sometimes tendentious, less than faithful to the original. He even interpolates words in translation in order to make his point. This is probably part of what has infuriated the other scholars and made them to impugn his motives.”
Meanwhile, the other scholars have also gratuitously labelled AbdulJabbaar with negative terms like zindiqi (unbelieving heretic), mulhidi (atheist), kafiri (unbeliever), jahili (ignorant), mahaukaci (lunatic), wawa (stupid, foolish), dan iska (worthless), la’ananne/tsinanne (accursed). He has been discursively kicked out of the fold of Islam.
He has also been accused of plagiarizing the work of Mahmud Abu Rayyah in writing his own book while deceptively letting on that he has been conducting independent research. I have Abu Rayyah’s book, but alas I don’t have AbdulJabbaar’s text to compare.
He has been charged with insulting the Prophet, which to me seems a stretch, a long stretch, a part of the polemics borne out of mutual suspicion of evil motives. And he has stated several times that his object is to defend the sanctity of the Prophet that has, in his understanding, been subverted by some narrations. There seems to be an impasse here. They have indirectly instigated Muslims to attack him – many preachers and scholars have said that they would not stop the people from taking action against him.
Pious sentiments got whipped up. Some people even say that Kano was on the verge of exploding. They finally got the State Government to ban him from further public preaching and close his centre.
Because of his actual attack on some revered Companions and the perceived attack on the inviolate personality of the Prophet himself, his condemnation has been near universal. Even the former Emir of Kano, Muhammadu Sanusi II has lent his voice to the condemnation. I recall that he also chastised the Shi’ites in the aftermath of the 2015 Zaria Massacre.
Notably, it has been mainly, but by no means solely, Shi’ite preachers and scholars who have been bold enough to speak in his support. Many sympathisers have self-censured and kept mum.
AbdulJabbaar and his supporters feel that he has been unjustly treated and has not been given a fair hearing. I also think that he shouldn’t have been gagged. I think this public debate being organized by the government is an attempt to address this perception of unfairness.
So far, this exchange between AbdulJabbaar and his interlocutors, as seen in countless videos on Facebook and YouTube, has been acrimonious, polemical, and full of invectives in which the substantial arguments are often difficult to extricate.
Will this public debate change anything? Will he even cooperate to have a real debate? Who will be the judge? How will the ‘winner’ be decided? Will it matter to the followers of the two sides?
“AbdulJabbaar’s frequently expressed desire for a debate comes across as half-hearted. If his ‘debate’ with Alkassim Hotoro is anything to go by, I doubt if anything will come out of this one.”
In that much publicized debate, he surprisingly kept hedging and putting up caveats. He shirked from defending a book written with his own hand. He was less than brave. However, after the ban, he has reiterated his readiness for his views to be challenged and even disproved.
So, let’s wait and see.
This piece was first published on Mr Balogun Facebook timeline
Headlines
Muhuyi Rimingado faults Kano lawmakers over delay in anti-drug bill
Nasiru Yusuf Ibrahim
The Chairman of the Kano State Multi Agency Taskforce on Drugs Abuse and Illicit Trafficking, Barr Muhyi Magaji Rimingado, has criticised the state House of Assembly over its alleged delay in considering a bill aimed at strengthening the fight against drug abuse and trafficking.
KANO FOCUS reports that Barr Rimingado said it was more than two weeks since Governor Abba Kabir Yusuf forwarded the proposed legislation to the Assembly, but lawmakers had yet to commence even its first reading.
He expressed his displeasure during a 90-minute interview on Makwantar Rikici, a programme on Lumana Radio.
The taskforce chairman said he was surprised that some influential members of the Assembly would allegedly seek to frustrate the passage of the bill because of their personal disagreements with him.
He argued that the proposed legislation was urgently needed to strengthen efforts to tackle the growing challenges of drug abuse, trafficking and insecurity in Kano State.
Barr Rimingado questioned why personal differences should be allowed to undermine legislation intended to protect the public and address a major social problem confronting the state.
He also warned individuals allegedly attempting to frustrate the activities of the taskforce that he would not be intimidated or discouraged from carrying out its responsibilities.
He vowed to resist any attempt to undermine the taskforce’s work, insisting that he would not allow personal interests to prevail over the collective interest of the people.
The taskforce chairman maintained that the fight against illicit drugs required the support and cooperation of all stakeholders, particularly the legislature, given the link between substance abuse and other social challenges.
Headlines
Kano police arrest woman, three others over alleged murder of 14-year-old boy
Nasiru Yusuf Ibrahim
The Kano State Police Command has arrested a woman and three other suspects over the alleged abduction and murder of a 14-year-old boy in a plot reportedly aimed at ensuring that her son becomes the sole heir to his father’s properties.
KANO FOCUS reports that the police said the suspects were arrested in connection with alleged criminal conspiracy, abduction, causing grievous hurt and culpable homicide.
According to a statement issued on Tuesday by the Police Public Relations Officer, Abdullahi Haruna Kiyawa, the incident was reported on April 29, 2026, by a woman from Danbare Quarters, Kumbotso Local Government Area, who said her son, Mahmoud Auwal, had been abducted.
The victim, who lived in Sheka Quarters, was 14 years old at the time.
Kiyawa said operatives of the command’s Anti-Kidnapping Squad began an investigation following the directive of the Commissioner of Police, Ibrahim Adamu Bakori.
He said the investigation led to the arrest of a 20-year-old suspect, Muhammad Musa Isma’il, of Sharada Quarters, on November 3, 2026.
According to the police, the suspect confessed during interrogation that he had deceived and lured the victim on April 20, 2026.
He reportedly identified two other accomplices as Abubakar Muhammad Isah, 27, of Semegu Quarters, and Auwal Muhammad, 26, of Dan-Agundi Quarters, both in Kano.
The statement said the suspects allegedly conspired to kill the boy and abandoned his body at the scene.
The corpse was later recovered by police officers attached to Kwalli Division during a patrol and taken to the mortuary of Sir Muhammad Sunusi Specialist Hospital.
Kiyawa said further investigation led to the arrest of the alleged mastermind, identified as Hajiya Rukayya Auwal, 20, of Mararaba Quarters, New Karu Local Government Area of Nasarawa State.
The police alleged that the three male suspects claimed to have acted on her instructions.
The statement further alleged that the woman hired another group of thugs to attack Muhammad Musa Isma’il in Mararaba, Karu Local Government Area, in an attempt to silence him and prevent him from exposing the crime.
The police said preliminary findings indicated that the woman was a co-wife of the victim’s mother.
According to the statement, the alleged motive was to eliminate her husband’s four children so that her only son could eventually inherit his father’s properties exclusively, although the husband is still alive.
The command said the case would be charged to court upon the conclusion of the investigation.
The Commissioner of Police condemned the alleged crime and assured the victim’s family and the public that the command would ensure that justice was served.
He also urged members of the public to provide credible and timely information to assist the police in preventing and detecting crime.
Headlines
ADC governorship candidate appoints campaign council in Kano
Nasiru Yusuf Ibrahim
The Kano State governorship candidate of the African Democratic Congress (ADC), Ibrahim Ali Amin, popularly known as Little, has constituted a campaign council to coordinate the party’s activities ahead of the forthcoming governorship election.
KANO FOCUS reports that the council is expected to oversee campaign operations and mobilisation across the state.
In a statement announcing the appointments, Adnan Mukhtar, Director of Media and Strategic Communication, said Alhaji Aminu Labaran Baba had been appointed chairman, while Hon. Bala Yau Bayco would serve as Director-General.
Yusuf Mamman Bature was named secretary of the council.
Other appointments include Hon. Mamina Bako Lamido as Director of Contact, with Hon. Abdullahi Dalhatu Dan Kano as deputy.
Alhaji Nasir Tahir was appointed Director of Support Groups, while Hon. Aliyu Ibrahim Muhammad would serve as his deputy.
Mukhtar himself was named Director of Media and Strategic Communication, while Alhaji Nasiru Hussaini Agalawa was appointed Director of Finance.
Other members include Hon. Magaji Yau Indabawa, Director of Public Affairs; Abba Abdulhadi Kofar Waika, Director of Youth Mobilisation; and Naja’atu Tasiu Abbas, Deputy Director of Youth Mobilisation.
Hon. Sharu Garba Umar Gwammaja was appointed Director of Special Duties.
For women mobilisation, Aisha Ibrahim Hassan, popularly known as Humaira, was appointed director, while Zahra Ibrahim Aminu was named deputy director.
The council also appointed Aisha Ibrahim Captain as Deputy Director of Women Mobilisation for Kano South, Binta Sayyada for Kano Central, and Amina Mahmud for Kano North.
The statement said additional directorates and appointments would be announced later.
The campaign council is expected to coordinate the ADC candidate’s political outreach, strategic communication and grassroots mobilisation across Kano State.
